Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Book Review: In Defense of Tenure




Kevin Mattson for Democracy Journal: In Defense of Tenure

Tenure....

A “vaguely fuzzy” term that emerged from abroad (Germany), academic freedom might sound akin to the First Amendment, but it’s not, for the obvious reason that it doesn’t apply to all citizens. Instead, it is a prerequisite for professional academic life, the autonomy necessary for making educated and trained judgments. Schrecker has her own analogy: “[J]ust as judges maintained their independence from the executive officials who appointed them, so too, professors were to be free from external interference.” Academic freedom protects controversial research and teaching from political reprisal. Teachers must be allowed the freedom to use their expertise and training to state truths and explain ideas that might be unpopular to students and readers of their research.

The argument for tenure rests on a largely forgotten history of academic injustice. There are some major cases. [...]

2 comments:

Kevin Scheunemann said...

Tenure is a "dodge" for many from having to usefully contribute to society.

There is more than 1 professor in UW system that meets this criteria.

Tenure is liberal code for "no accountability".

Kevin Scheunemann said...
This comment has been removed by the author.